Top 5 Cigars Everyone Should Have in Their Humidor This Year
We are calling all cigar enthusiasts! If you want to know which cigars made it to the top of the list in 2023, you're in for a treat. In this blog post, we'll reveal the five best cigars, according to Cigar Journal, that every connoisseur needs to try. 🌟
Welcome, Fellow Aficionados!
Today, we dive into the world of premium cigars and uncover the crème de la crème of 2023. Cigar Journal, a trusted authority in the industry, has meticulously selected these cigars. Join me as we explore these exquisite blends and discover what makes them unique.
Whether you're a seasoned enthusiast or just starting your journey into fine tobacco, this guide is your gateway to experiencing some truly exceptional smokes. So please sit back, prepare your palate, and let's indulge in the artistry of these masterfully crafted cigars together.
Number 5: Plasencia Alma Fuerte Eduardo

The Plasencia Alma Fuerte Eduardo is renowned for its complex and rich flavor profile and boasts a Colorado Claro wrapper that has aged for a decade. This cigar has earned high praise and deserves a place in every humidor. Rating: 90.
1st Third:
Upon lighting, you'll be greeted with deep and comforting notes of cocoa and almonds. These flavors set the stage for a luxurious smoking experience.
2nd Third:
Hints of nutmeg and cedar emerge, adding warmth and woodiness to the palate. The aging process contributes to developing nuanced flavors, including dark chocolate, plum, and cinnamon.
Final Third:
Finishing notes of oak and molasses come forward, providing a rich profile that includes black pepper, natural tobacco, fruit, and earth. This combination ensures a complex and satisfying smoking experience. 🌰🌿
Suggested Drink Pairing:
Aged Rum – The deep and rich flavors of an aged rum, such as Ron Zacapa 23, beautifully complement the cocoa and almond notes. The sweetness of the rum enhances the plum and cinnamon flavors, while the oak and molasses in both the cigar and the rum create a harmonious balance, making this pairing a delight for the palate.

Number 4: Rocky Patel Disciple Robusto

The Rocky Patel Disciple Robusto features a Mexican San Andrés wrapper and a blend of Nicaraguan fillers and binder. This medium—to full-bodied cigar has earned a 91-point rating from Cigar Aficionado.
1st Third:
Initial flavors of oak, earth, and spice dominate the palate, creating a robust start to the smoking experience.
2nd Third:
A transition to balanced black pepper occurs, with toasted cedar notes emerging around three-quarters of an inch into the cigar. Mocha notes begin to dominate, adding a rich, flavorful dimension.
Final Third:
Rich espresso beans and black pepper lead the flavors, with the raisin sweetness taking a back seat. The overall construction ensures a beautiful draw and a consistent burn. 🌶️🍫
Suggested Drink Pairing:
Single Malt Scotch—A smoky single malt Scotch, such as Lagavulin 16, pairs perfectly with the cigar's earthy and spicy notes. The Scotch's peatiness enhances the oak and earth flavors, while the caramel and vanilla undertones complement the mocha and espresso notes, creating a well-rounded and satisfying experience.

Number 3: Liga Privada Unico Serie Year of the Rabbit

The Liga Privada Unico Serie Year of the Rabbit is part of Drew Estate's esteemed Liga Privada line. It features a Connecticut River Valley Stalk Cut Habano wrapper. This cigar is known for its complex and evolving flavor profile and has earned a 93 rating.
1st Third:
Expect an impeccable taste with an incredible flavor profile, setting a high standard from the start.
2nd Third:
The dominant flavors transition to earthiness, barnyard, and leather, with barnyard notes replacing toastiness. Toastiness remains present alongside some generic cracker flavors.
Final Third:
The rich and complex flavors characteristic of the Liga Privada line continue, showcasing the quality and craftsmanship that make this cigar a standout. 🐰🌾
Suggested Drink Pairing:
Dark Beer – A rich and robust dark beer, such as a stout or porter, complements the earthy and leathery notes of the cigar. The beer's roasted malt flavors enhance the toastiness and barnyard notes, while its creamy texture balances the overall smoking experience, providing a smooth and satisfying pairing.

Before We Reveal the Top 2 Cigars...
Do you like this content? Please take a moment to subscribe, and we’ll hit your inbox every Thursday morning with this type of stuff. It helps us out a lot, and we appreciate it very much. Now, let's continue!
Number 2: J.C. Newman El Baton Belicoso

The J.C. Newman El Baton Belicoso carries a rich history and robust pyramid shape, earning a 93 rating.
1st Third:
Bold flavors of coffee, spice, and raisins greet the smoker, setting a rich and enjoyable tone.
2nd Third:
The cigar continues to impress with a balanced combination of flavors, maintaining its strength and complexity.
Final Third:
A consistent and robust profile of coffee and spice persists, showcasing the craftsmanship and tradition of the Newman family. ☕🌶️
Suggested Drink Pairing:
Bourbon – A well-aged bourbon, such as Pappy Van Winkle, pairs excellently with the coffee and spice notes of the cigar. The bourbon's caramel, vanilla, and oak flavors enhance the raisin sweetness and spice, while its smooth finish complements the robust profile of the cigar, making for an unforgettable pairing.

Drumroll for the Cigar of the Year: E.P. Carrillo Allegiance Confidant

The E.P. Carrillo Allegiance Confidant is a notable addition to Ernesto Perez-Carrillo's esteemed portfolio. Featuring an Ecuadorian Sumatra wrapper and a Nicaraguan binder and filler, this cigar has earned a 95 rating and the number 1 spot in Cigar Journal’s Top 25 of 2023.
1st Third:
Pepper notes are quickly complemented by caramel and cream, creating an engaging sweet and spicy flavor profile.
2nd Third:
Vanilla comes to the forefront, adding aromatic sweetness, while an earthy mushroom note delivers umami depth. Burnt wood notes provide a robust base.
Final Third:
The profile shifts towards a rich, peppery finish with gingerbread spice, nutmeg, and cinnamon. The intensity picks up, ending on a bolder note highlighting expert craftsmanship. 🌟🔥
Suggested Drink Pairing:
Cognac—A fine cognac, such as Hennessy XO, is the perfect match for the E.P. Carrillo Allegiance Confidant. The cognac's rich, fruity, and spicy flavors enhance the cigar's caramel, cream, and gingerbread spice notes, while its smooth, velvety texture complements the overall smoking experience, creating a luxurious and memorable pairing.

We hope you’ve enjoyed our blog on the top 5 cigars of 2023, as chosen by Cigar Journal Magazine. Please enjoy another in our growing line of videos, such as this ‘Cigar Lounge Etiquette’ on the screen now.




